Subscribe to Australasian Spartacist

View archives

	Australasian Spartacist No. 224	Spring 2014

On Malaysia Airlines MH17 Disaster

The statement below is reprinted from Workers Vanguard No. 1050 (8 August). In Australia the Abbott government seized on the fact that Australians were among those killed in the crash of flight MH17 in eastern Ukraine to grandstand on the world stage, sponsoring a UN resolution demanding an “international” investigation and unimpeded access to the crash site. Parroting their U.S. big brother’s claim that pro-Russian insurgents and/or Russians shot down the airliner, the government whipped up patriotic fervour. Abbott initially demanded scores of armed Australian troops and cops be sent to the crash site, ostensibly to recover human remains and collect evidence. After European authorities pointed out what a crazed military provocation this would be in the middle of the Ukraine war zone, Abbott settled for some dozens of unarmed cops.

Dependent on the guidance and support of the very same separatists that Abbott accused of shooting down the plane, the contingent of Australian Federal Police (AFP) eventually reached the crash site, despite the Ukrainian government’s military bombardment, had a photo op or two and got the hell out. The eastern Ukrainian separatists had already recovered and shipped out most of the bodies more than a week earlier. That the AFP caper succeeded in its intended purpose of rallying support behind the then-floundering and unpopular Abbott government was in no small part thanks to the ALP “opposition,” who fulsomely backed the government’s flag-waving campaign in the service of the U.S.-led crusade against Russia.

* * *

The crash of Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 in eastern Ukraine on July 17, apparently brought down by a missile, has been seized on by the Ukrainian government and its U.S./NATO backers as an enormous boost for their military campaign in the region. The moment the plane hit the ground, the Obama administration and its allies began howling that Russian strongman Vladimir Putin is to blame for the deaths of 298 innocent civilians on the plane, claiming that it was brought down by pro-Russian insurgents, who control areas of eastern Ukraine, using anti-aircraft missiles supplied by Moscow. Such touching concern for the lives of civilians is consummate hypocrisy on the part of the NATO imperialists. They brokered a fascist-infested coup in Ukraine in February and have backed the Kiev regime to the hilt as it organized the May 2 massacre of more than 40 people in Odessa and launched a provocative military assault in eastern Ukraine. Indeed, if not for Kiev’s war against the eastern insurgents, which includes aerial bombing of the civilian population, the tragedy of flight MH17 could never have happened.

We are in no position to know what brought down the plane. We do know that Washington and its mouthpieces have not produced a shred of credible evidence for their claim that it was shot down by the insurgents. We also know that it is notable that the Kiev government did not close this airspace following the shooting down of a Ukrainian Army transport plane only days before the MH17 disaster. And we know that, as things currently stand, the only forces to benefit from this horrific disaster are the Ukrainian authorities and their imperialist supporters.

If a civilian aircraft loaded with passengers was knowingly targeted, that would be a heinous atrocity. And, in fact, the Western imperialists are more than practiced in carrying out such atrocities. On 3 July 1988, the U.S. warship Vincennes, which had crossed into Iranian waters, shot down an Iran Air Airbus A300, incinerating 290 people. Five years before, on 1 September 1983, the U.S. sent Korean Airlines flight 007 into Soviet airspace on a spy mission. The South Korean 747 airliner refused to identify itself. Soviet forces assumed it to be the RC-135 spy plane that the U.S. flew on an overlapping route with the civilian plane and shot it down. To the imperialists, the deaths of the KAL 007 passengers were acceptable collateral for a provocative spy mission against the Soviet degenerated workers state.

Regardless of what happened with the Malaysia Airlines disaster, it does not change our position in defense of the right to self-rule for Donetsk and Luhansk, up to and including independence and/or amalgamation into Russia. Marxists are not neutral—we stand militarily with the people in Donetsk and Luhansk fighting against the Kiev regime. At the same time, we do not give any political support to their reactionary leadership, which is characterized by Great Russian chauvinism and riddled with anti-Jewish bigotry. Kiev government troops out of eastern Ukraine! U.S./NATO imperialists hands off! Down with imperialist sanctions against Russia!